125 Christmas Would You Rather Questions

We’ve pulled together a fabulously fun and festive list of Christmas Would You Rather questions for you to enjoy with your family and friends! 

Most of them are family-friendly and perfect for chatter around the Christmas Dinner table.  But we’ve included 25 more grown-up (& cheeky!) ‘Would You Rather’ quandaries to ponder too!

So whether you’re looking for a party ice-breaker,  an end-of-term class activity or a game to play whilst you digest your festive feast, scroll on down for our suggestions of Christmas questions to pose this year!

Ideas for Playing Would You Rather

Would You Rather Play ‘Would You Rather’ At Your Office Christmas Party Or Try To Guess Your Best Friend’s Answers?!

These questions are ideal conversation starters amongst friends.  They certainly don’t need any game formality to be enjoyed.

However if you’d like to make these Christmas Would You Rathers into a game, here are few ideas:

• Pop the questions up on a screen or board and do a poll for each to find the most popular answer.
• Have a handful of people complete the list in advance and the rest of the group has to try and guess whose answers they are looking at.
• Try and guess the answers of your other half, Mr & Mrs – game style.
• Create a fun debate – give two people 60 seconds each to speak in favour of their side of the would you rather conundrum.

We’ve created two free printable pdfs for you to use if you’d like to print out a set of questions. Scroll down to grab your copies.

And we’ve also designed a number of Christmas Would You Rather images that you are most welcome to copy and paste to your social media of choice to ask your friends what they would choose.  

However you decide to use the questions, have fun!

100 Christmas Would You Rather Questions: Family-Friendly Edition

1. Would you rather receive 20 small presents or 1 big gift?
2. Would you rather have Christmas every day or never at all?
3. Would you rather eat Roast Turkey for every main meal or Christmas Pudding for every dessert?
4. Would you rather be Frosty The Snowman or Buddy The Elf?
5. Would you rather have only Strawberry Delights in your Quality Street Tin or only The Purple Ones?
6. Would you rather have Matchmakers for fingers or After Eights for ears?
7. Would you rather have no Christmas or no Birthday?
8. Would you rather guide Santa’s sleigh or fly with a snowman?
9. Would you rather meet the Grinch or Ebenezer Scrooge?
10. Would you rather have a visit from the Ghost of Christmas Past or the Ghost of Christmas Future?

11. Would you rather receive 11 Pipers Piping or 12 Drummers Drumming?
12. Would you rather receive gifts from everyone you know or give gifts to everyone you know?
13. Would you rather have Brussels Sprouts with every meal or get Coal in your stocking?
14. Would you rather be Kevin from Home Alone or Kate from The Christmas Chronicles?
15. Would you rather spend Christmas in the snow or on the beach?
16. Would you rather receive 3 French Hens or 4 Calling Birds?
17. Would you rather go snowmobiling or husky dog sledding?
18. Would you rather be one of Santa’s reindeer or one of his elves?
19. Would you rather be Father Christmas or Mrs Claus?
20. Would you rather dance in The Nutcracker or be the Dame in a Pantomime?

21. Would you rather be left home alone at Christmas or lost in a new city?
22. Would you rather decorate 10 Christmas Trees or make 10 Christmas Wreaths?
23. Would you rather wrap 100 presents or write 100 cards?
24. Would you rather eat a whole yule log or a whole stollen?
25. Would you rather have Rudolph’s Red Nose or be Green like The Grinch?
26. Would you rather go to a Christmas Panto or Christmas Ballet?
27. Would you rather eat only Christmas leftovers for two weeks or have no Christmas leftovers at all?
28. Would you rather be a tester of Christmas toys or a taster of Christmas foods?
29. Would you rather play games all day long or watch movies?
30. Would you rather have candy canes for legs or chocolate fingers for arms?

31. Would you rather be an Angel on the Christmas Tree or a Gonk on the Sideboard?
32. Would you rather be an scout elf-on-the-shelf or an elf in Santa’s workshop?
33. Would you rather have Christmas lights for hair or a bauble for a nose?
34. Would you rather drink only hot chocolate or eat only Christmas cookies?
35. Would you rather skip Christmas Eve or Boxing Day?
36. Would you rather speak only in Christmas song lyrics or Christmas movie catchphrases?
37. Would you rather eat a Gingerbread House or live in one?
38. Would you rather eat only Brussel Sprouts or only Marzipan?
39. Would you rather dress up as Father Christmas or as an Elf?
40. Would you rather leave a treat on Christmas Eve only for Santa or only the Reindeer?

41. Would you rather have Pointy Elf Ears or a Santa Beard that instantly regrows?
42. Would you rather be Father Christmas or meet him?
43. Would you rather help a Friend Shop for Gifts or help Wrap them?
44. Would you rather Decorate your Tree with only Homemade Ornaments or fill the Floor Below it with only Homemade Gifts?
45. Would you rather eat 100 Chocolate coins or 20 candy canes?
46. Would you rather no Fairy Lights at Christmas or no Candles?
47. Would you rather give up Roast Potatoes or Pigs-in-blankets?
48. Would you rather untangle the Christmas Lights or do the Washing Up after Christmas Dinner?
49. Would you rather receive a tub of Cadbury Heroes in your Stocking or a Selection Box?
50. Would you rather travel on the Polar Express or the Grinch’s Sleigh?

51. Would you rather eat 10 mince pies or 10 Christmas cookies?
52. Would you rather make an advent calendar for someone or buy one for them?
53. Would you rather be in charge of eight flying reindeer or a village full of elves?
54. Would you rather be able to climb down chimneys or travel at the speed of light?
55. Would you rather have no Christmas food or no Christmas presents?
56. Would you rather wear a Christmas jumper that flashes or a Christmas jumper that jingles?
57. Would you rather travel to the North Pole on the Polar Express or in the sky with a snowman?
58. Would you rather have eyes made out of coal or a nose made from a carrot?
59. Would you rather write Santa’s list or have to check it twice?
60. Would you rather give the perfect gift or receive it?

61. Would you rather have the best Christmas tree or the best Christmas lights?
62. Would you rather deal with a grumpy reindeer or an angry elf?
63. Would you rather decorate only in silver & gold or without any silver or gold?
64. Would you rather get a hippopotamus for Christmas or a Partridge in a Pear Tree?
65. Would you rather have an attempted robbery by Harry or one by Marv (The Wet Bandit thieves from Home Alone)?
66. Would you rather be a gingerbread man or a snowman?
67. Would you rather face 100 elf-sized reindeer or 1 reindeer-sized elf?
68. Would you rather go overboard on Christmas lights or have none at all?
69. Would you rather have an advent candle or a traditional picture advent calendar?
70. Would you rather finish every sentence singing ‘And A Happy New Year’ or start every sentence ‘All I Want For Christmas Is’?

71. Would you rather help an Angel get their wings or the Grinch grow his heart?
72. Would you rather have the Grinch’s long green hairy fingers or Rudolph’s hooves for feet?
73. Would you rather live in a snowglobe or a gingerbread house?
74. Would you rather wear matching family Christmas PJs or matching Christmas jumpers?
75. Would you rather be able to hand deliver all your Christmas cards to friends & family or hand deliver your letter to Santa?
76. Would you rather be attacked by 100 small snowballs or chased by one enormous snowball?
77. Would you rather cook Christmas dinner or do the washing up afterwards?
78. Would you rather burn the Christmas turkey or burn the roast potatoes?
79. Would you rather watch The Queen’s Speech on repeat or join the Royal Family for Christmas?
80. Would you rather run out of Christmas dinner main course or Christmas dinner desserts?

81. Would you rather eat a Christmas roast dinner with chopsticks or your fingers?
82. Would you rather have a ‘Ho Ho Ho’ Santa laugh or an evil Grinch cackle?
83. Would you rather have a reindeer as a pet or an elf as your best friend?
84. Would you rather have spaghetti with syrup for breakfast or pancakes with gravy for dinner?
85. Would you rather have the M&S Christmas sandwich as the only Christmas sarnie option or have it discontinued?
86. Would you rather be stuck in Santa’s toy sack or down the chimney?
87. Would you rather get gifts you hate or no gifts at all?
88. Would you rather know someone exchanged a gift you thought they’d love or have them keep it a secret?
89. Would you rather have cheeks like roses or a nose like a cherry?
90. Would you rather have a creature stirring or an unwanted guest stirring?

91. Would you rather have small reindeer antlers or a reindeer tail?
92. Would you rather be in charge of cleaning Santa’s sleigh or cleaning the workshop?
93. Would you rather eat a mince pie for every meal in December or chocolate from a selection box?
94. Would you rather dress up to match your pet or dress up to match your family?
95. Would you rather get stuck like a snow angel or a snowman?
96. Would you rather buy all your Christmas gifts at a Christmas market or on the High Street?
97. Would you rather play monopoly for five hours or have a conversation about politics with your family?
98. Would you rather listen to “Merry Christmas Everybody” on repeat for 24 hours or sing it once in front of a 100-person audience?
99. Would you rather find a sixpence in the Christmas Pudding or the tiny screwdriver set in your Christmas cracker?
100. Would you rather be in Mickey’s Christmas Carol or The Muppets Christmas Carol?

25 Christmas Would You Rather Questions For Adults

1. Would you rather get your boss in Secret Santa or your mother-in-law?
2. Would you rather be snowed in alone or with your entire extended family?
3. Would you rather drink only mulled wine for a day or only hot chocolate?
4. Would you rather be naughty or nice?
5. Would you rather get £100 cash for Christmas or gifts from everyone that they chose themselves?
6. Would you rather be stuck in a lift with Clark Griswold (National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation) or Billy Mack (Love Actually)?
7. Would you rather be mentioned in The Queen’s Christmas Speech or included in the New Year’s Honours List?
8. Would you rather be taken out for Christmas dinner or have someone cook it for you at your home?

9. Would you rather have your home decorated by your family without you or decorate it alone yourself?
10. Would you rather spend Christmas with Bob Cratchit’s family or George Bailey’s?
11. Would you rather see your Mum kissing Santa Claus or kiss him yourself?
12. Would you rather dress up as sexy Santa or a naughty elf?
13. Would you rather listen to Band Aid’s Do They Know It’s Christmas on repeat or Paul McCartney’s Wonderful Christmastime?
14. Would you rather spend the day with Kurt Russell’s Santa or Richard Attenborough’s?
15. Would you rather have the Elf-On-The-Shelf watch you whilst your sleeping or Santa?
16. Would you rather receive a rude Christmas card from your Grandmother or send her one?
17. Would you rather star in the next Gavin & Stacey Christmas Special or the next Eastenders one? 

18. Would you rather have a village of elves at your disposal or go Christmas shopping with an unlimited budget?
19. Would you rather be regifted a gift you gave someone or regift someone something they gave you?
20. Would you rather walk around with mistletoe above your head or sit on a sprig holly?
21. Would you rather have buck’s fizz on Christmas Day morning or mulled wine on Christmas Eve?
22. Would you rather sing Silent Night or Santa Baby in the office Christmas karaoke?
23. Would you rather spend hours getting the perfect Christmas family photo or not have one at all?
24. Would you rather have too much to drink in front of your boss or your in-laws?
25. Would you rather get engaged at Christmas or married at Christmas?

More Christmas Game Inspiration

In the mood for more festive fun?  Check out more of our Christmas games & ideas at the links below:

• Christmas Food & Drink Quiz
• Christmas Movie Bingo
• Easy Christmas Family Game Ideas
• Mince Pie Taste Test Party
• Christmas Songs Emoji Quiz

Inspired you to create your own Christmas Would You Rather questions?  Share them with us in the comments below.  We’d love to join in!